Something is broken
They can be, as a tap you turn on when you need work this month. They are a poor foundation, because a bought lead is rented: you pay for each one, the price is set by the marketplace, and it stops the day you stop paying. Below is what the two companies say about their own charges, in their own words, and how to work out whether they pay for you.
In their own words
Neither company publishes a price list. Prices are shown inside your account. Everything below is from their help pages as read in November 2026. Check their pages, they change.
| Angi | Thumbtack | |
|---|---|---|
| When you are charged | When “both you and the homeowner show interest in connecting with each other.” Angi also says you are charged “whether or not you open or respond” to a lead. | You pay for leads, which Thumbtack describes as new customers who reach out to you directly. For the jobs it calls Opportunities, you pay the price shown only if the customer responds to you. |
| What sets the price | “Lead fees change based on task, homeowner location, and demand for the work.” | The type and size of the job, how many pros are available, and your market. You set lead prices with a slider. |
| Billing | Weekly without a subscription; monthly with an annual subscription. A monthly budget is a target and can be passed by one lead. | Not covered in the pages we read. |
| If a lead is bad | You can ask for a credit if the lead is under 45 days old, you tried to call within 24 hours, your account has no overdue balance, and you have no annual subscription. Credits go toward future leads and expire after six months. | You can ask for a refund within 45 days. Thumbtack says refunds are at its sole discretion. They go to your Thumbtack balance unless you ask for the card within 10 business days of approval. |
| An automatic refund | Not covered in the pages we read. | If a customer does not reply to any pro they contacted within 72 hours, and you replied through Thumbtack within four business hours. |
Source: Angi Help Center, leads · billing · lead credits · Thumbtack Help, pay for leads · refund policy · Fair Shot refund, read November 2026.
Read the fine print
A bad lead on Angi comes back as credit, not cash. By Angi's own page, a lead credit is applied to future lead charges and expires if unused in six months. And the page lists having no annual subscription as a condition for asking.
Speed is part of the deal on both. Angi's credit rule expects a call within 24 hours. Thumbtack's automatic refund needs your reply within four business hours. If you cannot answer a new lead quickly, you are paying full price for a worse chance.
You are rarely the only one. Thumbtack's own refund page talks about a customer not replying to “any pro they contacted”, so customers there can contact several. Angi's pages we read do not say how many pros get a lead. Ask before you buy.
We have not run an account on either one. We will not tell you which is better, and we have no figure for what a lead costs in your trade. The number that matters is your own, below.
Your own number
For calls you miss while on a job, the missed-call calculator does the same kind of plain arithmetic with your numbers.
The regulator
In March 2022 the Federal Trade Commission filed a complaint against HomeAdvisor, which is affiliated with Angi. The FTC alleged that the company had made false, misleading or unsupported claims about the quality and source of the leads it sold to service providers: that many leads were from people not planning to hire soon, that many did not match the provider's services or area, and that job-win rates were claimed higher than its own data supported.
Those were allegations. The case ended in 2023 with HomeAdvisor agreeing to an order that required up to $7.2 million in redress and barred misrepresentations about its leads. The matter was withdrawn before a hearing, so there is no ruling that the company broke the law. In November 2023 the FTC said it sent 110,372 checks, more than $3 million in total, to service providers.
Source: FTC press release, 11 March 2022 · FTC, 23 January 2023 · FTC, 28 November 2023, read November 2026.
We say nothing here about Thumbtack and regulators, because we found nothing first-hand to report.
Rented and owned
You pay each time. The marketplace sets the price and the rules for credits. Stop paying and it stops. The customer found the marketplace, not you.
Someone found your Google profile, read your reviews, opened your site and called. No fee for that lead. The profile, the reviews and the site are still there next month.
Reviews build one job at a time, and Google says search changes can take from hours to several months to show. So do not cancel the marketplace on day one.
Source: Google Search Central, SEO Starter Guide, read November 2026.
Straight answers
Work out your cost for each won job over ninety days. If it leaves a healthy margin and you can answer leads fast, it can be. If you are slow to answer or the cost eats the job, it is not.
The FTC's 2022 complaint describes HomeAdvisor as affiliated with Angi and also doing business as Angi Leads. For what the product is called today, check Angi's own site.
Angi's help page says you are charged for leads whether or not you open or respond to them, once you and the homeowner have both shown interest in connecting.
The help pages we read explain lead charges and billing but do not give a membership or subscription price. Ask Angi for the full cost in writing before you start.
We have not run either, so we will not rank them. Compare them on your own cost for each won job.
Ask the marketplace directly. Thumbtack's refund page refers to customers contacting more than one pro. If a seller says exclusive, ask them to define it.
A complete Google profile, a review asked for after every job, a site that answers fast, and a text back when you miss a call. None of it is quick. All of it stays yours.
Keep reading
The longer version: what owning your leads means and what to build first.
Own your leads →Speed matters most on a shared leadOne text back when you miss the call, so the customer has a reply while you are still on the ladder.
Missed-call text back →Reviews are the first thing you ownWhen to ask, the words, and Google's rules.
Get more reviews →What to build firstIt depends on your reviews and your customer list.
Where should you start →We will do the arithmetic with you on the call.